Advertisement

Sign up for our daily newsletter

Advertisement

Obesity and social networking sites: Social networks can affect weight, happiness

This correlation, described in by a team that analyzed data from the longitudinal Framingham Heart Study, is well established. Cult Sociol.

Matthew Cox
Monday, April 5, 2021
Advertisement
  • Social media may be an even less expensive avenue, particularly if an existing platform e. Obesity, the authors conclude, needs to be seen not simply as a clinical issue but as a public health problem.

  • Article PubMed Google Scholar. Thomas J, Harden A.

  • One paper published during the production of this paper dites identified after the review was completed and another two papers were identified by a colleague working in this field. Here, community organizations and community groups [ 184950515558 ] were identified as relevant ties for the adoption of a good diet and physical behaviours.

Publication types

One such study obesity and social networking sites Facebook to provide weight management programme content aites podcaststogether with text messaging to programme strategy reminders, recorded weight loss in the intervention group [ 64 ]. Undermining of nutrition and exercise decisions: experiencing negative social influence. As social support is a broad concept, it was sub-divided.

The authors involved in the review discussed and confirmed the themes between them and other members of their research team as part of a process of reflexive dialogue against framing the analysis according to a single perspective. In each scenario text or quotevarious components have been identified and coded individually, showing their positive and negative effects on health. Additional file 1: All data-driven. Health Expect. The following levels of analysis with their initial characteristics are adapted for this article based on relevant research of other authors [ 35758182838485 ]:.

Paradigmatic controversies, contradictions and emerging confluences, revisited. Global, regional, and national prevalence of overweight and obesity in children and adults during a systematic analysis for the global burden of disease study Weight loss intervention adherence and factors promoting adherence: a meta-analysis. The following levels of analysis with their initial characteristics are adapted for this article based on relevant research of other authors [ 35758182838485 ]:. A qualitative exploration of experiences of overweight young and older adults. Nevertheless, social pressure exerted by close contacts in concrete social events e.

Mobile Utility Navigation

I agree with you angelo social networking is a bane! Diabetes-related terms were included in the list of terms connected with LTCs. See Subscription Options.

The term social media will be used in this review as this term encompasses these additional capabilities of online social networking services. Proc Nutr Soc. It needs to be highlighted that although grey literature was also reviewed, it was not included in the final analysis of review findings since it did not provide sufficient relevant information on the topic. Chung JE. Emerging evidence supports the use of social media to augment health promotion interventions, by providing social support to those undergoing health behaviour changes. The ways in which these processes were explained in the papers are presented in the following sections.

Thus, this CIS aimed to generate concepts and theory where those concepts could be integrated and interpreted rather than summarising obesity and social networking sites per se. Social or Antisocial media — The Silence before the Storm. Am J Prev Med. Carrying out qualitative analysis. In terms of weight management, research has shown that individuals who have social support are more likely to have better weight loss outcomes than those who do not [ 25 ]. Social support in online weight loss networks.

  • J Nutr Educ.

  • Complex system approach with inductive constructs. This holds true for human health and body mass, too.

  • With regard to negative effects, individuals with specific cultural norms might for instance influence the quality and amount of food intake Table 3Q4. A critical perspective.

If you want to sign in with your Facebook ID, click the connect button, otherwise click here and sotes your existing password. Do the researchers provide a clear account of the process by which their findings were reproduced? Social networks and health. Search all BMC articles Search. Nurs Outlook. Implement Sci. Article PubMed Google Scholar

These cultural groups can reflect ethnicity or education level. These findings social networking sites not been replicated in all settings: in their survey of Australian adults Christian et al. From social integration to health: Durkheim in the new millennium. MP participated in the design of the study and contributed to the analysis and interpretation of data.

Background

In vivo social comparison to a thin-ideal peer promotes body dissatisfaction: a randomized experiment. Use of formative research and social network theory to develop a group walking intervention: Sumter County on the move! Labianca G, Brass DJ. Carter B et al.

Friends and siblings of opposite genders showed no increased risk. The first of these considers the structural aspect of networks, including the patterns of linkages between actors [ 21 ]. Diabetes Educ. Oxford: Routledge; Implement Sci.

Rather, there is a direct, causal relationship. Friends were also mentioned in 11 articles baillie hamilton obesity key players [ 2748495154556063656668 ]. Bronfenbrenner U. Campus Alert. Critical interpretive synthesis of barriers and facilitators to TB treatment in immigrant populations.

Recent Blog Articles

Views and experiences of behaviour change techniques to encourage walking to work: a qualitative study. Social networks and social norms are associated with obesity treatment outcomes. Given the way the study was designed, however, it is quite possible that the effect of social norms is "even higher" than 20 percent, Fowler says. Applications of social network analysis to obesity: a systematic review.

One paper published during the production of this paper was identified after the review was completed and another two papers were identified by a colleague working in this field. The impact of exposure to the thin-ideal media image on women. Again, no surprise, since spouses share meals and may have similar exercise habits. To improve inter-reviewer reliability, spot checks were carried out on discarded references by a third reviewer. Using community insight to understand physical activity adoption in overweight and obese African American and Hispanic women: a qualitative study.

Interventions seeking to manipulate social networks by targeting obesity and social networking sites individuals might be effective in influencing weight [ 6 ] but revealed little about the processes through which they might be effective. Is there evidence that friends influence body weight? Network processes are responsible for tie formation and outcomes [ 86 ] located within a social context that shapes practices, behaviours and the roles and functions that networked individuals achieve [ 49 ]. Rather, there is a direct, causal relationship.

Adult obesity: applying all our health. Sign Up. Support and sabotage: a qualitative study of social influences on health behaviors among rural adults. For instance, as shown in T4 in Table 3individuals might make decisions about their own health whilst they are comparing their body size with others. Health Expect.

Recent Blog Articles

Thus, different agents were sifes at two levels of analysis meso and micro levels. They were then grouped in wider categories or data-driven themes. Interestingly, geographical distance between persons in a social network appears to have no effect. This pattern was also observed in siblings. This is the case when the family control what an individual is eating at home.

  • Exploiting social networks to mitigate the obesity epidemic.

  • Negotiating diet in networks: a cross-European study of the experiences of managing type 2 diabetes. More concretely, in 7 articles [ 27506061626364 ] the tie strength frequency of contact and feeling of closeness with members of the family or healthy companions consistently describes higher diet quality as it can be seen in T19 and T20 in Table 3.

  • Its been happening for years in forums, but social networking takes it to the next level. J Womens Health.

  • In social networks, though, transmission can happen even though the people may be hundreds of miles apart.

  • A critical perspective.

Barnett-Page E, Thomas J. That doesn't seem to be a valid email address. Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in social networking reviews. And a new study, published online May 5 in the American Journal of Public Healthdrills down to see just how these social forces might be at work. To address this gap in developing an integrated and holistic conceptual approach, a critical interpretative synthesis was undertaken following a line of argument synthesis as an analytical strategy. The study found that when an individual becomes obese, the chances that a friend of theirs will become obese increase by 57 percent.

Possible influences include food production, food consumption, societal influences, individual psychology and activities, activity environment and the linkages networing them. Enabling pathways to sites equity: developing a framework for implementing social capital in practice. Internet World Stats: Facebook users in the world. Bottero W, Crossley N. All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article [and its supplementary information files]. Lessons learned from public health mass media campaigns: marketing health in a crowded media world.

Connect with others who understand.

Prev Med. Understanding the social networks that form within the context of an obesity prevention intervention. Effects of weight-focused social comparisons on diet and activity outcomes in overweight and obese young women.

NSF undertook the review and drafted the paper. In limiting the scope of this review to relational networks, the review is unable to take into networikng the wider social and environmental context that shapes particular networks. Role of social support in lifestyle-focused weight management interventions. The development of multi-agents coalitions between the different individual components of the data-driven themes created, using cross-level influences might be suitable to apply in the complex environment where individuals live.

Interactive, online health promotion obesity and social networking sites for specific health issues have been shown to provide social support for behaviour change. As these neteorking show, social media is effective at providing a support to network members. This indicates that sense of belonging is important but that other forms of social capital might influence obesity. Voluntary organizations and community groups as new partners in diabetes self-management and education: a critical interpretative synthesis. In this review, theoretical saturation signalled the end of the identification of articles in which social relationships were related to the adoption of ORBs in adults. Recent Blog Articles.

Mobile Utility Navigation

From a health policy perspective, it aocial be relevant to modify contextual and individual factors such as paying greater attention to how we can create or modify infrastructures and environments to practise physical activity or enhance the self-efficacy of avoiding unhealthy practices e. Social connections seem to be key. Google Scholar Download references. Barriers to uptake of physical activity in community-based patients with schizophrenia.

Environmental determinants of healthy eating: in need of theory obesity and social networking sites evidence. Thus, developing multi-agent coalitions is a driver that highlights the necessity of the combination and influence between these different concepts, developing power of cumulative effects. The more we know about how healthful habits, positive attitudes, and wise lifestyle choices spread through communities, the more it will help experts use natural social networks to improve public health. Meso-level: describing relationships with healthcare professionals and other individuals from the community or locality neighbourhood, suburb, city.

Additional file 2: Coalitions. Int J Nurs Stud. I agree with you angelo social networking is a bane! These results could have utility for health policy, considering the design of innovative interventions based on the integration of social networks and other contextual factors at multiple levels of analysis. It has reached epidemic proportions globally, with at least 2. The network facet of social pressure showed dual effects [ 4951535462 ].

  • Full details of data extraction of the selected studies can be found in are included in the additional information Additional file 2.

  • Two examples with the involvement of different levels of analysis are illuminating:.

  • New Media Soc.

  • As Fowler points out, they are "very easy to act on. As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content.

  • It was relevant here as broad spectrum criteria for the inclusion and exclusion of identified relevant articles.

  • Networks are formed by individuals and the ties among them and thus, it is relevant to continue the description of networks by examining simple properties or measurements of these social structures [ 86 ].

Health Soc Care Community. Oxford: Routledge; If socially gleaned attitudes are not netaorking driving force spreading obesity among social circles, what is? Social relationships are considered to be relevant mediators operating in open systems of a tangled and complex set of events, contexts, resources, practices, and priorities [ 15 ]. London: NICE;

In social networks, though, transmission can happen even though the obesity and social networking sites may networling hundreds of miles apart. It also seemed to reach across at least three degrees of separation, spreading, for example, zocial a friend to the friend of a friend and then to the friend of that friend. These results could have utility for health policy, considering the design of innovative interventions based on the integration of social networks and other contextual factors at multiple levels of analysis. Having an obese neighbor did not make a person more likely to be obese, but having a friend or relative who was—even if that person lived hundreds of miles away—did. She and her colleagues found themselves surprised how small an effect the norms had on a person's BMI. Maybe the people who are becoming obese from social networks are on them too much and not doing things they use to such as: walking, exercize, and moving around.

Support Science Journalism

Anf Although there has been increasing acceptance that social networks are important to our understanding of obesity, there has been limited understanding about the ways in which such networks shape the development of overweight and obesity. This last example, which was extracted from the same article as the previous one, shows how adding an extra data-driven theme party, social event changes the effect into one, which is more negative. The effect of descriptive norm information on food choice. Pediatrics ; 6 :e Contributor Information Katie Powell, Email: ku.

London: Sage; As they analyzed the data, the researchers also looked closely at the baillie hamilton obesity of gender, smoking, socioeconomic status, and geographic distance. Negotiating diet in networks: a cross-European study of the experiences of managing type 2 diabetes. Although the aim is to provide a whole and innovative vision of an event, certain factors might require more in-depth analysis using other strategies and more empirical work. MyObesityTeam is the social network for those living with obesity. All family changes for each study participant, such as birth, marriage, death, and divorce, were recorded.

Similarly, through qualitative focus groups, Bertoni et al. Discussion The WHO has also recognised the importance of social resources as a valuable agent for behaviour change in health promotion. It might be difficult to put these findings into practice, however: a review of the evidence relating to social support in weight loss interventions found inconclusive evidence to detect the influence of social support on intervention outcomes [ 66 ]. Use of formative research and social network theory to develop a group walking intervention: Sumter County on the move!

Mobile Main Navigation

We applied truncations, acronyms and the booleans OR and AND to combine terms within each column and between columns from Table 1. Methods To address this gap in developing an integrated and holistic conceptual approach, a critical interpretative synthesis was undertaken following a line of argument synthesis as an analytical strategy. This CIS offers an opportunity to gain novel insights regarding how social networks influence the adoption or abandonment of positive and negative ORBs in adults with obesity, overweight or risk of obesity. The integration of relevance and rigor was essential in the selection of articles.

Curr Opin Endocrinol Diabetes Obes. Conflicting perspectives of obesity causation and intervention amongst overweight people, health professionals and policy makers. A review of the nursing literature. Thousand Oaks: Sage; Oxford: Blackwell; Barriers and facilitators of weight management: perspectives of Arab women at risk for type 2 diabetes.

Social processes influencing the development of overweight and obesity. Barbovschi M et al. Current Cardiovascular Risk Report. Considering the ubiquity and accessibility of ICT, protecting the privacy, data and confidentiality of intervention group members is another concern that has been raised [ 49 ]. Obes Rev.

Disclaimer:

It has reached epidemic proportions sires, with at least 2. Get the emotional support you need from others like you, and gain practical advice and insights on managing treatment or therapies for obesity. The frameworks held up in the analysis: The first describes the case in which social norms between people converge "and that makes you both behave the same way," Brewis explains; the second, occurs when two people might have different social norms, but a friend's social norms "shape [the other's] behavior even if they don't internalize them"; and the third possibility—"it's not really due to the relationship at all," but rather something else that is related to body size, such as simply frequently seeing friends who are overweight.

Nightingale G. For instance, as shown in T4 in Table 3individuals might make decisions about their own health whilst they are comparing their body size with others. Social networks and social norms are associated with obesity treatment outcomes. Heart Health. London: Routledge;

The social science literature increasingly suggests that social networks are important in the maintenance of general health and protection from networling range of diseases [ 1 ]. Internet World Stats: Internet users in the world by regions November Dysthymic mood — Symptoms of anxiety and low self-esteem are a consistent correlation with all types of Internet addictions. Abstract Background In an estimated 1. Peer support by family members was key to acquiring good dietary habits [ 56 ] Table 3Q8 and group support to performing physical activity [ 49 ], as of Q9 in Table 3. Social ties and mental health.

You are not alone.

For example, social pressure by family at micro-level has typically positive effects on health. Account already exists We found an account on MyObesityTeam matching the email address of this Facebook account. Another limitation is the restriction on searching only in the English and Spanish language.

  • The lack of an existing holistic theoretical framework of how social networks influence the adoption of ORBs motivated the selection of lines-of argument synthesis LOA as the analysis strategy. The use of social media for health promotion and weight management is still very much in the formative stages.

  • Am J Public Health.

  • Participant retention seems to be problematic, but this issue is not limited to weight management [ 21 ] or social media [ 67 ] interventions. Social networking in online support groups for health: how online social networking benefits patients.

  • First Name. To avoid the risk of missing relevant information, other strategies have been used to fit better with the exploratory nature of the aim [ 42 ].

  • Hale L and Guan S. Introduction to multilevel social networks.

Networking sites example, there may be cases where family members might be supportive or not with diet Table 3Q25 and Q In this latest case, it is shown how a positive effect is reversed into a negative one by adding an extra component contextual factor. Online interactivity Including an interactive component to an intervention may be especially helpful for intractable public health conditions such as obesity, and may provide cost-effective and accessible weight management interventions [ 60 ]. Following this, we cannot consider in the same level of analysis e. For example, a recent study revealed that individuals that reported experiencing social connectedness through Facebook had lower anxiety and depression, and greater subjective wellbeing [ 50 ]. Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews.

I guess it depends on how you use social networks and how much you use them. Learn More. PloS One. MP participated in the design of the study and contributed to the analysis and interpretation of data. World Health Organisation.

Disclaimer:

Thus, per example, this review has shown that the coalition family type of link, micro-level with peer support network process, micro-level has potential positive influences on health. Join today! Recent Blog Articles. Views and experiences of behaviour change techniques to encourage walking to work: a qualitative study.

Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article doi Website-delivered physical activity interventions: a review of the literature. Department of Health: England; Interventions could also target key community groups, for example church networks or other religious places of worship.

Qual Quant. Barriers and facilitators to physical activity amongst overweight and obese women in obesity and social networking sites afro-Caribbean obesitt a qualitative study. Brewis says that her group hopes to start studying the role of social norms in different countries as well, such as in India and Paraguay. Is obesity contagious? Also, we have decided to propose the meso-level as the limit of the analysis because of the relevant amount of available.

Get smart. Sign up for our email newsletter.

But in their analysis obeskty the Framingham data, Fowler says, his team found that "it's true that your environment has an impact on you, but it doesn't seem to be the reason" for your body weight. Another relevant network process is homophily [ 48495268 ], the tendency of pairs of individuals to share the same characteristics [ 20 ], described as a positive network process to exercise -e. Birks M, Mills J. These different multi-agents coalitions produce and, therefore, acknowledge both positive and negative health outcomes in the individuals.

Behav Neyworking. J Consum Behav. J Epidemiol Community Health. On the other hand, having high levels of income is associated with better education and the self-report of good self-management skills Table 3T All authors gave final approval for this version of the manuscript to be published, and take full responsibility for its content. Hitze B et al.

An experimental study of homophily in the adoption of health behavior. Qualitative research practice. When Facebook is easier than face-to-face: social support derived from Facebook in socially anxious individuals. The generation of a more detailed and higher-order structured theoretical framework might be useful to identify potential healthy and unhealthy scenarios. Social relationships are considered to be relevant mediators operating in open systems of a tangled and complex set of events, contexts, resources, practices, and priorities [ 15 ].

Obes Res Clin Pract. Physical activity interventions using mass onesity, print media, and information technology. This is so true. Through qualitative methods in a similar setting, Daniels [ 62 ] provides insight into how this might be experienced, demonstrating that family demands make it harder for women to prioritise weight loss.

Background

Will new guidelines for heart failure affect you? These findings have not obesity and social networking sites replicated in all settings: in their survey of Australian adults Christian et al. With regard to positive effects, the combination of family type of link, micro-level with peer support network process, micro-level is the most important because it was the most mentioned in the literature thirteen timesshowing the engagement of individuals in health behaviours.

Networking sites interventions. The two theory-driven themes point to different coalitions with positive and negative effects on health. Using community insight to understand physical activity adoption in overweight and obese African American and Hispanic women: a qualitative study. Already a subscriber? If socially gleaned attitudes are not the driving force spreading obesity among social circles, what is? The micro-level is represented more than the meso-level -mentioned in 21 articles [ 1827454849505152535455565758616264656668 ] with 13 articles identifying social support as an essential network process for the adoption of healthy practices [ 184849505153545556576465 ].

In addition, participants had also listed networkking information networking sites their closest friends. Serrano Fuentes, N. Mathematical and quantitative research powerfully describes the structure of networks and documents whether their effects are significant or not, in a statistical and theoretical sense [ 21 ]. DOCX 33 kb. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Another advantage for our research interests is that a CIS also has flexibility and is convenient in terms of appraising quality, using relevance e.

  • St-Onge M and Shechter A.

  • The specific gap regarding what and how network properties and processes together with other factors produce positive and adverse health outcomes in adults with ORBs has been addressed to a limited extent previously [ 373839 ]. Social forces.

  • Nutrition knowledge and food consumption: can nutrition knowledge change food behaviour?

  • There is some indication that people who are normal weight might reject obese people socially [ 70 ]. Psychosocial correlates of healthful diets: baseline results from the working well study.

The authors applied a citation snowballing technique to generate lists of related articles regarding the aim. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. However, there is a specific need to focus on both positive and negative results [ 4041 ] and for multilevel approaches to be bridged to create an integrated theory, specifying relationships between phenomena. Also, networking with healthcare professionals and neighbours were identified as a means of getting involved with behaviour change, as illustrated in T14 and Q4 in Table 3. Over the last 25 years, the incidence of obesity among U. Published : 28 August London: Routledge;

Thousand Oaks: Sage; Harvard Medicine magazine three times a year. DOCX 33 kb. Multilevel network analysis for the social sciences: theory, methods and applications.

These themes obesity and social networking sites developing multi-agent coalitions and cross-level influence. Barnett-Page E, Thomas Neworking. As social support is a broad concept, it was sub-divided. The role of peer social network factors and physical activity in adolescent girls. Another relevant network process is homophily [ 48495268 ], the tendency of pairs of individuals to share the same characteristics [ 20 ], described as a positive network process to exercise -e.

Neighbourhood social capital: measurement issues and associations with health outcomes. Barriers and facilitators of weight management: perspectives of Arab women at risk for type 2 diabetes. Open in a separate window. Psychol Sci. Behav Med. Barbovschi M et al. Katie Powell, Email: ku.

This is obesuty case when the family control what an individual is eating at home. As with the internet, social networking sites can also take advantage of mobile technology, and could provide another avenue for health promotion interventions. Returning to Campus. J Am Coll Heal. Glancing up or down: mood management and selective social comparisons on social networking sites. De Jong E et al.

Mobile Main Navigation

Will new guidelines for heart failure affect you? Sign up for our free newsletters. In these examples, different aspects of networks together with contextual factors are present.

  • In this review, three zocial themes were created. Social support, accessed obesity and social networking sites friends and family networks, has been linked to higher self-efficacy in online support networks for diet and physical activity interventions: social support seemed to provide structure, encouragement and purpose in relation to physical activity in a study of motivation amongst individuals with schizophrenia [ 58 ].

  • Thank you for sharing this insightful article.

  • Identifying the processes of change and engagement from using a social network intervention for people with long-term conditions. During the first iteration of theme development, labels for themes reflected the language used within the papers.

Obesity, the authors conclude, needs to be seen not simply as a clinical issue but as a public health problem. Is our healthcare system broken? Background Obesity is a leading public health challenge in developed and developing anv. There is a group called the National Empowerment Center from the Boston area where people with mental illness can support each other. Harvard Medicine News weekly. Peer support by family members was key to acquiring good dietary habits [ 56 ] Table 3Q8 and group support to performing physical activity [ 49 ], as of Q9 in Table 3. Social network characteristics associated with weight loss among black and hispanic adults.

Help me, I'm fat! The relationship between happiness and health: evidence from Italy. Bavelier D et al. Nevertheless, these were sufficient to attain theoretical saturation [ 4773747576 obesity and social networking sites, 77 ]. Klein WMP. Related to this, American undergraduates have been shown to calculate their risk of becoming overweight through comparison with others they identify with, defined as friends or average same-sex undergraduate peers, irrespective of absolute risk [ 47 ]. As there is an indication that social networks are important, we need to know more about the ways in which social networks might be effectively manipulated to improve diet, body weight and physical activity norms.

All authors agree to be accountable for the accuracy and integrity of the work. In the study, happiness spread more readily between members of the same sex than between people of the opposite sex. Its been happening for years in forums, but social networking takes it to the next level. Currently, the most relevant are targeting influential individuals to spread healthy information and behaviours through interpersonal ties [ 2829 ] and creating opportunities for health-supportive relationships to be maintained [ 293031 ]. Women's social eating environment and its associations with dietary behavior and weight management. Weight loss intervention adherence and factors promoting adherence: a meta-analysis. Dynamics and nature of support in the personal networks of people with type 2 diabetes living in Europe: qualitative analysis of network properties.

Given LM. Flemming K. Start meeting others who understand.

The people you live with, work with, talk to, email, chatter baillie hamilton obesity on Twitter and Facebook—your social network—can be good medicine, or bad. Obesity and overweight. Its been happening for years in forums, but social networking takes it to ovesity next level. But in their analysis of the Framingham data, Fowler says, his team found that "it's true that your environment has an impact on you, but it doesn't seem to be the reason" for your body weight. Meso level influences on long term condition self-management: stakeholder accounts of commonalities and differences across six European countries. As they analyzed the data, the researchers also looked closely at the influence of gender, smoking, socioeconomic status, and geographic distance. Staying Healthy.

With regard to the meso-levelenvironmental factors described in 7 articles [ 48495052535556 ] sites lack of conducive built environments were considered to be the main barriers to exercise Table 3Q11whilst community resources such as group activities stimulate the adoption of healthy activities in older people Table 3Q Hawkins N et al. In terms of weight management, research has shown that individuals who have social support are more likely to have better weight loss outcomes than those who do not [ 25 ]. The systematic approach to searching and reviewing the literature improved the development of clear inclusion and exclusion criteria. Exploiting social networks to mitigate the obesity epidemic.

Sidebar1?
Sidebar2?